Silicone: The most comfortable for long-term wear. Also the most affordable body-safe option. It has vibrating options. Rating:Naughty Candy Heart Anal Plug was rated 4 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

Not nearly as sexy (or in as many options) as the Rosebuds Cristal series, but at a much cheaper price point. Plus, remember sex toys need to be made from a non-porous material like silicone, glass or stone, because these can be thoroughly cleaned and won't cause infections/pass on STIs.We recommend to avoid this cheap starter plug for the same reasons as the above plug. The product description here is even more vague, stating it’s made from a “firm-but-flexible rubber jelly material.” Powerful Vibrations: 6 intensity settings and 15 vibration patterns to deliver powerful anal orgasms. Controlled by a wireless remote, or from buttons on the base of the plug. The round tip isn’t as easy to get inserted as something more slim and tapered, like many of the other starter butt plugs on this list.

Wearing a butt plug during any kind of sex act can enhance your pleasure and potential orgasms, thanks to the tons of nerve endings around the anus. You can get silicone butt plugs, vibrating butt plugs, glass anal plugs and plugs that are designed for prostate massage. For smooth and safe penetration, coat the plug with a lubricant. It’s made of silicone, which is anal-friendly material. The phthalate and latex-free plug is perfect for all skin types.This water-based formula doesn’t stain sheets or clothing unlike oil-based lubes. It is also compatible with latex and polyurethane condoms for slippery safe sex